Cheima Moufdil
The debate over who holds the title of the No. 1 pound-for-pound fighter in MMA persisted throughout 2024, fueled in large part by UFC CEO Dana White. White staunchly supported Jon Jones as the sole contender for the distinction, dismissing other UFC champions, including Islam Makhachev, whose growing resume has led many to argue he is the true pound-for-pound best fighter today.
Javier Mendez, Makhachev’s trainer, has a different perspective, asserting that there shouldn't even be much of a debate. For Mendez, the discussion boils down to a combination of activity and level of competition, two areas where he believes Makhachev clearly surpasses Jones.
“This is what I always say: How many fights does Jon Jones have in the last four years? Tell me. How many?” Mendez said in an interview with Hablemos MMA. “If you said six or seven, OK. But how many does he have? Two in four years. No, you need to fight more than that (for pound-for-pound best). If Islam were to do the same, I’d put Jon Jones at No. 1 – but he hasn’t fought (as much). That reason alone puts Islam at No. 1.”
Jones, widely regarded as one of the greatest MMA fighters of all time, has indeed only competed twice since 2021. In contrast, Makhachev has fought eight times during the same period, often facing the top-ranked fighters in his division. According to Mendez, Makhachev’s body of work includes not just activity but a consistently high level of competition.
“Islam’s fights have always been against No. 1,” Mendez said. “Alexander Volkanovski was the best featherweight in the world and pound-for-pound, and he fought him. Everyone he’s fought has been very tough. The styles of all those guys were very good.
“Jon Jones fought Miocic, who was (42), and hadn’t fought in like four years, so he wasn’t the same. Jon Jones is supreme. He’s an excellent talent and has never lost in his whole life. It’s tough to critique him because he’s fought everyone, but he just hasn’t fought much in the last four years.”
Mendez stressed that the pound-for-pound discussion is not the same as naming the greatest fighter of all time. While he acknowledges Jones as the GOAT for his unparalleled achievements and undefeated career, Mendez believes the pound-for-pound title reflects current dominance and activity, where Makhachev stands out.
“The pound-for-pound conversation is now,” Mendez said. “I’m not going around saying that Islam is the greatest of all time. I’m just saying he’s the pound-for-pound best right now. That’s all. I’m not saying anything else.”
Makhachev (26-1 MMA, 15-1 UFC) will have the opportunity to solidify his claim to the top spot further when he defends his lightweight title against Arman Tsarukyan in the main event of UFC 311 on January 18 in Los Angeles, California. The bout marks a rematch of their 2019 encounter, where Makhachev earned a unanimous decision victory in a hard-fought contest. Tsarukyan, who has since evolved into a top contender, will be looking to avenge that loss and claim UFC gold.
With the stakes high and the pound-for-pound debate raging on, UFC 311 promises to set the tone for what could be another pivotal year in MMA.