Cheima Moufdil
Manchester United used to be the gold standard in football. In the 1990s and 2000s, the club dominated on the pitch, led the sport commercially, and projected influence worldwide. Today, that dominance is gone—not because the club lacks ambition, but because the structures behind the scenes consistently fail.
The dismissal of Ruben Amorim is being framed as a necessary decision, yet focusing on the manager alone misses the bigger picture. United has fallen into a familiar pattern: managers arrive with bold ideas, only to inherit squads, contracts, and club structures that make it almost impossible to succeed. Recruitment rarely fits the coach’s vision, wage structures are misaligned, and decision-making is fractured across executives, directors, and owners. The result? A manager becomes the convenient scapegoat when results wobble.
Even the arrival of Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s Ineos in 2023—brought in to modernize governance and inject capital—hasn’t corrected the underlying problems. Despite promises to restore United to the top of English, European, and world football, the club continues to stumble over the same issues that have plagued it since Sir Alex Ferguson left in 2013. Lines of authority remain unclear, footballing philosophy struggles to filter through, and accountability is diffused.
Financially, the cost of this instability is staggering. Amorim’s departure with 18 months remaining on his contract could cost £12 million, adding to nearly £100 million spent on managerial exits in recent years. Beyond the numbers, the constant turnover hurts United’s reputation, making it harder to attract top talent and compete with clubs like Real Madrid, Barcelona, Bayern Munich, and Liverpool.
The core problem is not who stands on the touchline. It’s the lack of a coherent, club-wide strategy—one that aligns ownership, recruitment, squad planning, and long-term vision. Until Manchester United addresses these structural issues, the next managerial appointment will likely be just another temporary patch in a long-running cycle of hope and disappointment.