Alkass English
Sept 28 (Reuters) — Manchester City may face sanctions ranging from fines and a points deduction to relegation after being found guilty of 114 breaches of Premier League financial rules. However, the road to any enforcement remains long, with the club expected to appeal.
A soccer source, speaking on condition of anonymity, confirmed Friday's media reports that the independent panel found City guilty on all but one of the charges, telling Reuters on Monday that the process is expected to drag on.
City Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak responded to reports of the guilty verdict with an open letter to fans. He noted that the club—which has consistently denied wrongdoing since the charges were announced in February 2023—remains confident of proving its case.
"The Premier League process still has a long way to run, and our confidence and intent in proving the club’s innocence is just as strong as when this began," he wrote on Saturday.
A three-person board would hear the case if City choose to appeal the independent judicial panel's guilty ruling. The club cannot take the matter to sport's highest court, the Court of Arbitration for Sport, which previously overturned City's two-year Champions League ban imposed by UEFA for overstating sponsorship revenue between 2012 and 2016.
However, a formal appeal process may be a long way off given the sheer volume of charges, which cover nine seasons from 2009 to 2018 and required a four-year investigation before being officially brought forward.
A Long Time in Limbo
It is entirely possible that the current Premier League season—in which City currently lead the table after five straight wins—may end without an official final verdict or confirmed punishments, leaving the world's richest soccer league in limbo.
Even if a verdict and penalties are announced mid-season, subsequent appeals could delay the imposition of any sanctions until after the campaign concludes. Conversely, if the case is wrapped up before the end of the campaign, a severe points deduction could theoretically plunge City from title contenders into a relegation battle. If the charges stand, the penalty might even be severe enough to make avoiding the drop practically impossible.
Furthermore, City could face even harsher retroactive punishments, similar to the fate Juventus suffered following the "Calciopoli" corruption scandal that rocked Italian soccer two decades ago. While multiple clubs faced heavy sanctions for the manipulation of referee assignments, Juventus paid the highest price: they were stripped of two Serie A titles and relegated to Serie B. The 2004–05 Serie A season was left without an official champion, while the 2005–06 title was awarded to Inter Milan.
A similar retroactive reshaping of the Premier League's championship history could significantly impact other clubs and the broader credibility of the competition. Additionally, if City are ultimately judged to have gained an unfair sporting advantage, they could face separate legal challenges from rival clubs claiming lost prize money and missed financial opportunities.